Home Coalitions Clean and Fair Elections Malacca election: Electoral Commission must improve election management

Malacca election: Electoral Commission must improve election management

ANIL NETTO/ALIRAN

Follow us on our Malay and English WhatsApp, Telegram, Instagram, Tiktok and Youtube channels.

Persatuan Bertindak Pilihan Raya Bebas dan Saksama (Tindak) calls upon the Electoral Commission to take responsibility of the election mess and mismanagement that occurred in recent state elections.

We, Tindak, were involved in the Malacca state election, which concluded on 16 November, through the commission’s sanctioned pemerhati (election observer) programme and petugas pilihan raya (poll workers).

Combined through reports we obtain from other sources, we express displeasure over the commission’s failures in preparing poll workers for this given election.

While poll workers, who implement and administer elections, are not commission officers, their conduct and competence demonstrates the quality of the front face of the commission during an election.

All poll personnel are appointed and report to the returning officer while they are trained by the commission (at least once or, at worst, once only).

We, Tindak, have been engaging with the commission every year since 2019 on how it could improve the poll workers programme.

While improvements were made, our reporting of the conduct of the 2026 Malacca state election shows that the commission has done an incomplete job. We have noticed that it barely takes action on the observer reports that we file in over the years, and the lack of or limited acknowledgment of our special reports on poll worker matters.

We are aghast at the implementation of the optical character recognition – voter attendance (OCR-VA), where we have questioned the logic of such a tool since its first implementation in the Ampangan state seat in the 2026 Negeri Sembilan election.

We have engaged with the commission from time to time through our election observer reports and specialised poll workers programme study reports through formal and informal channels. Plus, our observers have asked specific questions about OCR-VA during the commission’s observer training sessions for October 2026.

Sadly, the commission has demonstrably failed on this account to make strident reforms. Hence, we are left with no choice but to publicise all reported infarctions, errors and poor practices through this press statement.

For the Malacca election, we have asked our observers to lodge formal complaints to the commission through official channels.

Specific problems

Poor layout for the semakan isi peti undi

We told the commission in the recent Negeri Sembilan state election that they should mandate standard requirements for the comfort and ease of work of the presiding officer and polling clerks who are carrying out the semakan isi peti undi.

The semakan isi peti undi is a half-day event, usually in the morning, where all presiding officers and polling clerks (one for each polling stream) are given all election materials for the polling day. Checks are done to ensure a sufficient quantity of materials is issued and any issues with materials are rectified.

Since every state constituency has its own returning officer, the choice of location and subsequent layout for this activity varies from one constituency to another (no consistency).

Elections are one unique occasion where one can impose a standard across all constituencies. Yet the commission does not seem to take this opportunity.

We told the commission recently, through our Negeri Sembilan election observers report that there should be at minimum a table and two chairs for each polling stream for the semakan isi peti undi.

The commission did not respond and failed to act. In the Pengkalan Batu, state seat, the semakan isi peti undi was done in a spacious hall (a mini-stadium). Yet the returning officer’s team allocated one table and four chairs to accommodate two polling streams. Each table will have election materials for two polling streams.

There was no need to cram every presiding officer and the polling clerks of each polling stream in a spacious hall. Half of the hall was empty. The irony is the hall was situated outside the Pengkalan Batu state seat (in the northern area of Ayer Keroh state seat).

In the Bukit Katil state seat, the hall given was spacious but not a single table was given to any of the presiding officers and polling clerks. A chair was given for each polling stream where the chair hosts all the election materials. The presiding officers and their polling clerks must check each election material on the ground floor. It is a messy and disorganised process due to the crammed nature of the set-up.

We were informed that the PA system was functioning well for this state seat’s semakan isi peti undi, where instructions could be heard clearly. The chair positioning (between the chairs) is close. All these details’ points to no logic of a poor layout and utilisation of space for the semakan isi peti undi.

In the Ayer Keroh seat, things were done properly. The returning officer’s team organised a table with two chairs for each polling stream. The presiding officer and polling clerks could carry out the semakan isi peti undi with ease.

The question we ask to the commission: why the hesitancy to standardise a basic process such as semakan isi peti undi? The commission cannot excuse itself by saying it needs to placate the returning officers (so their cooperation remains secured) nor should it be oblivious to election observers (who report to the commission), and some commission officers could be present for this election stage.

READ MORE:  Malacca election: Political realignment taking shape

Our commission chairman and commissioners are known to visit semakan isi peti undi activities in different state seats and sadly, they only witness an ideal layout and structure like what we found in Ayer Keroh.

Incomplete notice for polling stream door at SJK (C) Yun Hwa in the Pengkalan Batu state seat

It is noted in our previous observer exercises like the 2025 Kuala Kubu Baharu by-election, where notice of the details of the polling stream was done in an incomplete manner.

This notice will include the number of the polling stream, range of sequence numbers and closing. For polling stream number 9 of this school, around 7.30am, our observers found the notice on the door had missing information on the sequence number and closing times plus a child-like drawing of the number 9.

Ballot box checks delayed at SJK (C) Bukit Beruang in Ayer Keroh

It was reported that there were slight delays in the ballot box checks required before the opening of the polling stream at 08:00 for the voters. By right, at around 07:40, the presiding officer and polling clerks should be in the stream for the preparation of ballot box checks.

The ballot box remained around a yellow bag at around 07:35. The presiding officers and polling clerks of all polling streams were found taking pictures at the gate of the polling centre at around 07:40. Fortunately, this incident did not affect the start of polling.

Confusion of polling centres in Ayer Keroh

We noticed there were cases of the voters getting confused about which polling centres they should go.

Here is the first example – Sekolah Rendah Arab JAIM Kampung Tun Razak and Sekolah Rendah Agama JAIM Kampung Tun Razak are two polling centres of the polling district of Kampung Tun Razak. These similar-sounding polling centre names are near each other.

Many voters made the mistake of heading to the wrong polling centre and had to leave when the mistake was found. What transpired initially was many voters entered the polling centre under the assumption that they were in the right location (for both polling centres).

The mistake was found when the voter entered the polling stream and found that the electoral roll did not have their names or when the voter was checked by the poll worker at the gate. It was found that poll workers may have assumed the voters were in the right polling centre without checking.

This resulted in the barung counter (where checks should have been made) becoming remarkably busy.

A comparable situation appeared for the confusion of Sekolah Jenis Kebangsaan (Cina) Bukit Beruang – the official polling centre of the Taman Bunga Raya polling district in Ayer Keroh – and Sekolah Kebangsaan Bukit Beruang – the polling centre of the Bukit Beruang polling district of the Bukit Katil seat. These polling centres are adjacent to each other.

Our research showed that Sekolah Jenis Kebangsaan (Cina) Bukit Beruang is situated outside the Ayer Keroh seat but in the Bukit Katil seat (a problem that the commission has been reminded about, from time to time by us over the years).

Moreover, there was a mistake for the notice at the barung itself. Several voters came to this Chinese school first and only found out they were at the wrong polling centre when they entered the polling stream.

The electoral roll checkers and polling centre guides spotted these voters and directed them to Sekolah Kebangsaan Bukit Beruang.

Ballot box not sealed or improperly sealed:

We received multiple reports from our observers throughout the day and reports from polling and counting agents through our members that ballot boxes were not sealed or improperly sealed before the polling started.

The problem is the issue was discovered much later after 08:00 as our observers were visiting different polling streams of different polling centres.

Here are the specific details:

Polling stream 1 (Sekolah Kebangsaan Tun Razak, Bukit Katil seat) – The ballot box was found unsealed (discovered at around 08:30).

Polling stream 5 (Sekolah Kebangsaan Tun Razak, Bukit Katil) – The ballot box was improperly sealed (discovered at around 08:30).

Polling stream 4 (Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Bukit Baru, Bukit Katil) – The ballot box was found unsealed (discovered at around noon. Our observer informed the presiding officer about this. It was found the presiding officer did not have enough knowledge about this procedure or received enough guidance on how to go about this.

Polling stream 6 (Sekolah Rendah Jenis Kebangsaan (C), Keh Seng, Bukit Katil) – The ballot box was found unsealed (discovered at around 17:00).

Polling stream 3 (Sekolah Menengah Teknik Melaka, Pengkalan Batu) – The ballot box was improperly sealed (discovered at around 13:00). Only mousetail was done, and one side of the ballot box was not properly sealed.

READ MORE:  Israel is headed for catastrophe - Israeli journalist Gideon Levy

Improper actions by presiding officers /poll workers

This section covers other miscellaneous infarctions, mistakes and erroneous information carried out by the presiding officers or poll workers. This is sourced not only from our observers and poll workers, but also from new sources and other allied NGOs.

The following are the incidents:

In the Pengkalan Batu state seat, the DAP candidate was nearly stopped from exercising his right to cast his vote for the seat by the presiding officer. This incident took place at Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Agama Sultan Muhammad Batu Berendam (09:00).

This incident took place one hour before our observers came to the polling centre The said candidate was receiving the ballot and the presiding officer interrupted the polling process.

The presiding officer received false information from a group that candidates are not allowed to cast their votes.

However, the polling process resumed when the presiding officer received instructions from the authorities to proceed with polling and allow the candidate to cast his vote. The candidate was forgiving, as he said the presiding officer is young and could be a first-time presiding officer.

In the Pengkalan Batu seat, PN-Bersatu candidate Norhizam Hassan Baktee was denied entry into a polling stream in Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Bukit Piatu and observe the process from outside.

The candidate asked the poll worker at hand (no designation detail was given), demanded an explanation and things cooled down subsequently. The candidate was allowed to observe the polling stream. The said worker also allowed the candidate and accompanied him to observe all polling streams.

Polling Stream 3 (Dewan Terbuka Taman Seri Cempaka, Pengkalan Batu) had a bad layout, which was determined by the presiding officer. The place where the voters cross the ballot is the similar positioning to tables for polling clerks (this could have affected the secrecy of the vote).

The presiding officer of polling stream 3 (Sekolah Jenis Kebangsaan (C) Bukit Beruang in the Ayer Keroh seat) was giving voters the option to dip their left or right finger, based on the fact that the voter could be right-handed or left-handed.

The presiding officer of polling stream 2 (Sekolah Jenis Kebangsaan (C) Bukit Beruang, Ayer Keroh) seemed to not to enforce ‘no mobile phone’ use even if the voter was holding on to the phone at hand all the way into the polling stream.

The compound or entrance of Sekolah Jenis Kebangsaan (Cina) Bukit Beruang (in the Ayer Keroh seat) witnessed some weakness of allowing vehicles with party logos to enter the 50-metre fifty restricted areas to drop off the poll centre supervisor, and police saw this in the morning, but no action was taken. Subsequently, the poll workers and police tightened the enforcement of ‘no party logos’ within the 50-metre restriction.

At Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Tun Mutahir (no specific polling stream specified) in the Ayer Keroh seat), there was improper management of orang yang dipercayai (the trusted people to assist voters who have difficulties in marking their ballots by themselves).

There was a case of a partially blind voter accompanied by her mother in a polling stream. The presiding officer and polling clerks were aware of her sight disabilities and assisted her registration.

One of the polling clerks then led the voter to an area where ballots are to be marked, and the polling clerk positioned himself or herself close to the said area.

However, the issue at hand is the polling clerk was found peering over the box where the voter is marking the ballot to ensure the ballot is filled up (could have affected the secrecy of the vote).

Another issue is the presiding officer may not have established whether the voter’s sight disability was serious enough to affect the ability of the voter to mark the ballot accurately. The presiding officer should have advised the use of orang yang dipercayai for such circumstances.

Polling stream 3 (Sekolah Rendah Agama JAIM Al-Rahman Bukit Pulau, Bukit Katil seat) had no dedicated boxes for voters to place their phones before casting their votes. The presiding officer mentioned to our observer that such boxes were not given to them.

Polling streams 1 and 2 (Sekolah Menengah Kebangsaan Bukit Baru, Bukit Katil) witnessed an improper implementation by the presiding officers to ask voters to place their phones in designated boxes.

In one of the polling streams (Sekolah Kebangsaan Jalan Datuk Palembang, Bukit Katil), a polling agent was found using an electronic device to key in data (voter sequence number) and this usage was done in an open manner (an observation from an allied NGO). The commission was informed of the incident by the observer from the allied NGO.

Polling stream 2 (Sekolah Rendah JAIM Duyong, Duyong seat) witnessed polling clerk 2 performing the checks on the fingers (as opposed to the actual practice by polling clerk 1). Polling clerk 2 was busy checking the name of the voter in the electoral roll (this is the duty of polling clerk 1, not polling clerk 2).

READ MORE:  California Governor-elect Xavier Becerra celebrates projected win

Polling stream 1 (Sekolah Kebangsaan Seri Duyong, Duyong) witnessed a lapse in the monitoring of orang yang dipercayai or improper management of the orang yang dipercayai. Our observer was at polling stream 1.

A woman and her husband in a wheelchair came in, passed through polling clerk 1, polling clerk 2 and at polling clerk 3 and the wife took the ballot paper. She did the talking while her husband was silent and headed to the voting area. She stopped the wheelchair there, went to the box, took a pen and crossed the ballot sheet, went straight to the ballot box and slipped the paper in. She came back to the wheelchair and pushed it out of the classroom.

In the second case, a woman and her elderly daughter in a wheelchair also came in the same polling stream. Similar to first case, the same process was repeated, the woman crossed the ballot paper and put it into the ballot box. No one advised her.

In the third case also, a woman brought her mother in a wheelchair, crossed the ballot paper on behalf of her mother and put it into the ballot box.

In one of the polling streams of Sekolah Kebangsaan Merlimau (Merlimau seat), a voter was unable to cast his ballot after discovering someone else had voted using his name. The OCR-VA was meant to minimise such situations.

Rationale of OCR-VA

The commission must understand the goal of OCR-VA and how the goal is to tackle a specific problem. One of the desires of the commission is to ensure that the voter turnout count emanating from polling streams is accurate.

This begs the question – since when did the inaccuracy of voter turnouts become an issue in elections?

Second, we ask whether the commission has studied the implications of the OCR-VA considering the presence of the Election Offences Act.

The OCR-VA, which scans the identity card number, captures the information of the voter’s name and sequence number. This information is streamed out to commission’s system. Doesn’t the commission know that streaming the individualised voter turnout could be in violation of the Election Offences Act?

Third, has the commission allocated sufficient training for poll workers on the use of the OCR-VA? Our observers found in one of the polling streams, the polling clerk 2 was incorrectly scanning the identity cards using the OCR-VA. At around 10:30, polling clerk 2 was made aware of the correct way to use the OCR-VA and polling clerk 2 had to manually enter the unscanned identity card details in the system. The commission could have better spent its resources on resolving poll worker-related matters as opposed to introducing modern technologies.

We, Tindak, will submit our observer report findings and specialised poll worker reports to the commission in the weeks to come. We do expect the commission to study and carry out the relevant fixes as soon as possible.

We call upon the Electoral Commission to implement the following:

  • Democratise poll worker recruitment across the country. Open it to members of the public to participate in the election process as part of election administration.
  • Emulate Tindak’s poll workers’ rigorous recruitment criteria. The commission must get the best of the best from members of the public and civil servants to be part of poll workers. Recruitment criteria such as upper age limits, locations, preferences to returning officers’ government office should be done away with. Commitment, flexibility and agility are essential criteria for one to be part of the poll worker team.
  • Carry out regular and multi-form training. Currently, all poll worker candidates receive one round of poll worker training, and they would be lucky if there is a second round. As a matter of fact, the commission does not even call this training but briefing (“taklimat”). When combined with the first two points, continuous training will ensure high competence of future poll workers. Relying on the goodwill of returning officers to call the commission for additional trainings or initiatives of selected commission state offices for multiple training session is no longer an option. Emulate Tindak’s monthly training for poll workers and election officers.
  • Act on the observer findings by all NGOs and government organisations for each election. Demonstrate to each observer group what the commission can do or cannot do. The last round of feedback session of observer findings by the commission was done back in 2019, and none has been carried out since. Similarly, act on Tindak’s poll workers’ reports.
  • Any improvements in elections must be made based on a solid understanding of what is required. While implementation of the OCR-VA may have its merits, the commission should have spent its resources on strengthening the poll worker programme.

The commission must take responsibility for this spread of incompetence, poor practice and bad actions of poll workers. It has the constitutional mandate to carry out elections in a free and fair manner!

Danesh Prakash Chacko is the chairperson of Persatuan Bertindak Pilihan Raya Bebas dan Saksama (Tindak).

The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

AGENDA RAKYAT - Lima perkara utama
  1. Tegakkan maruah serta kualiti kehidupan rakyat
  2. Galakkan pembangunan saksama, lestari serta tangani krisis alam sekitar
  3. Raikan kerencaman dan keterangkuman
  4. Selamatkan demokrasi dan angkatkan keluhuran undang-undang
  5. Lawan rasuah dan kronisme
Support our work by making a donation. Tap to download the QR code below and scan this QR code from Gallery by using TnG e-wallet or most banking apps:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted

Most Read

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x