Home Media statements 2014 Media Statements Aliran condemns disruption of anti-Sedition Act gathering

Aliran condemns disruption of anti-Sedition Act gathering

Join us on Telegram and Instagram for the latest.

Aliran is appalled at yesterday’s disruption of an anti-Sedition Act gathering at Speakers’ Square in Penang by a group of thugs.

thugs at anti-Sedition Act gathering in Penang 12 Oct 2014

These louts drowned out the event organised by Gerakan Mansuhkan Akta Hasutan calling for the repeal of the Sedition Act, by shouting obscenities, heckling and creating a ruckus. Activists and supporters of the GHAH were forced to leave the Esplanade as their safety was not assured.

The aggressive and threatening behaviour witnessed at Speakers Square is a shocking demonstration of a trend of growing intolerance and fascist behaviour. Incidents such as this make a mockery of one of the objectives of Vision 2020, which is to establish a mature, liberal and tolerant society. Where is the moderate Malaysia the prime minister spoke about earlier this month at the 69th United Nations General Assembly in New York?

An outsider would be forgiven for thinking that that the rowdies owned the public space at Speakers Square and are able to dictate who can and cannot speak there. But the fact is that Speakers Square is a public space designated in May 2010 by the Penang state government as a place to practise and celebrate freedom of speech. The space belongs to the people of Penang and no group can deny any other the right to speak there.

The police, some of whom were in plainclothes, were present at this incident and were meant to ensure public order. But by not intervening early to separate the groups and allocating time for each group to speak, they allowed an escalation of violent behaviour by the pro-Sedition Act group resulting in the anti-Sedition Act activists being severely threatened and denied the space to speak – all because they held a different view. Both groups may have had opposing views but they each have a right to their views and the right to express those views.

READ MORE:  Police need more compassion and discernment to rebuild reputation

This was not the first time that thugs have disrupted a peaceful function at the Speakers Corner. They had been a public nuisance previously and got off scot-free. On one occasion, one of the rowdies even threw a shoe at the Chief Minister’s car.

Shouldn’t the police, knowing all this, have taken precautionary action to pre-empt such unruly behaviour? If only they had nabbed some of the rowdies and charged them for being a public nuisance, this would not have happened.

Freedom of speech is not the freedom to prevent other people from speaking. In a democracy, it is imperative that the police are trained to manage groups with opposing views to ensure that the right to freedom of expression and of speech in public spaces – what more, Speakers’ Square – is upheld.

Aliran condemns the disruption of the peaceful gathering of GHAH activists and supporters and reiterates the demand for the immediate repeal of the Sedition Act .

Aliran executive committee
13 October 2014

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Hunter X Hisoka
Hunter X Hisoka
15 Oct 2014 8.21pm

Don’t expect to ask those bozo’s into senses …

No matter how problematic is the speech, no one not ever throw a single punch to anyone but what did the police do? NOTHING even video caught red handed!!!!!

… i believe Penang will be more peaceful without them.

Ed G
Ed G
15 Oct 2014 8.43am

The use of such barbaric method as counteraction against those who opted to promote their cause by democratic and civilized means is by itself an admission of defeat. Deep inside those thugs (or those behind them?) is actually an awareness of the indefensibility of the manner upon which the Sedition act is callously and selectively applied, notably by the police and the AG’s office. But then, the thuggish behavior of those pro-Sedition act activists may lend greater credence to the abolishment of the act. First, it gives the impression that there is no credible or reasonable argument to counter the call for the abolishment of the act. Second, it gives the anti-Sedition movement much greater publicity (or dramatization?) than could possibly be achieved merely by speaking at the speaker’s corner. Third, it put the ball at the government’s feet to act against those trouble-makers, failing which it would run the risk of being accused of being in complicity with the thugs; thus being seen as equally bankrupt morally and intellectually. And all these certainly runs counter to Najib’s effort to promote himself on the international stage… Read more »

14 Oct 2014 7.44am

Can you expect (them) not to bite or samsengs not to fight ? Just look at the picture what a typical (pro-)Umno samseng looks like. Now you know why the country is coming to an end with samseng like that behind Umno.