Home Media statements 2015 Media Statements Anwar can be treated overseas – if the authorities agree!

Anwar can be treated overseas – if the authorities agree!

Follow us on our Malay and English WhatsApp, Telegram, Instagram, Tiktok and Youtube channels.

Is it a fact that Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim cannot receive medical treatment abroad? Is it a fact that the law does not allow prison inmates to do so?

Utusan Malaysia has reportedly quoted Supri Hashim, the Prisons Department deputy director in charge of prison policy, as having stated “that Section 37 (1) of the Prisons Act 1995 clearly stated that a prisoner could only be treated in government hospitals, and not private hospitals, let alone overseas” (The Malaysian Insider, 10 November 2015)

But Section 37(1) does not seem to support his contention. At best, it is only his opinion and it is a matter of his interpretation of Section 37 (1). That is all – and nothing more!

What does Section 37 (1) of the Prisons Act 1995 state exactly?

37. Illness of prisoner:

(1) In case of serious illness of a prisoner confined in a person in which there are inadequate facilities for the treatment of that prisoner, the Officer in Charge, or in his absence, the next senior prison officer on duty, may, on the certificate of a Medical Officer, make an order for the removal of the prisoner to a government hospital.

There is no mention whatsoever of “private hospitals” or “overseas” in this section. It does not specifically state that prisoners cannot be treated at “private hospitals” or “overseas.”

It does not state why prisoners cannot be treated at “private hospitals” or “overseas.” It does not state that the only treatment available to prisoners is the “general hospital” and nowhere else.

This only means, as we understand, that cost is involved when prisoners are referred to “private hospitals” or “overseas” for treatment and that the government is not obliged to pick up this expensive bill.

READ MORE:  PH's power and potential now protected and prolonged

That is the only reason why “government hospital” is mentioned. That is a fair stand to be adopted by the authorities.

That additional cost involved must be borne by Anwar if he chooses to be treated elsewhere. That cannot be passed on to the taxpayers.

But the worrying fact remains that Anwar and his family and supporters harbour fears and misgivings about his treatment locally, especially when it involves general anaesthesia.

They have publically stated, “We don’t trust the system, because the system can deny Datuk Seri Anwar basic treatment like physiotherapy.

“We don’t trust the system to do an operation where Anwar would be under general anaesthesia, and so on.”

The Parliamentary Opposition Leader has taken a strong position in this matter as well. “We don’t trust the system here, because even the attorney general can be transferred without his knowledge,” Dr Wan Azizah was quoted as saying.

The issue of trust highlighted by the Parliamentary Opposition Leader is a serious one, particularly when it involves the life of a Malaysian, any Malaysian for that matter.

The government must immediately move to address this issue if it believes in the saying that “where trust is thin, suspicion is thick”.

In a ‘trust deficit’ situation such as that alleged by the Parliamentary Opposition Leader, should anything untoward occur through an invariably innocent human error, that innocent oversight can take on a life of its own that the government does not need.

The government will be well advised to allow the treatment of Anwar to be performed in a private hospital overseas since this effectively means transferring the risk attendant in the this situation. The simple expedient is for the appropriate Minister to designate the overseas private hospital chosen by Anwar “as ‘a general hospital’ pursuant to section 37 (1) of the Prisons Act 1995”.

READ MORE:  60 NGOs applaud PM's directive to admit students unable to pay fees

The government need not fear that Anwar would abscond himself once he is outside the country for treatment. If he wanted to be free, he would have fled the country and sought asylum quite easily.

But he deliberately and freely chose to remain in the country and face the consequences. There is no reason to believe that he would abandon his principles and betray the trust of Malaysians and turn tail and abscond.

As it is, there is no law prohibiting Anwar from receiving treatment overseas. All that is required is a compassionate consideration, in the name of humanity, to allow Anwar to seek treatment of his choice.

Will the government show such humanity in the name of decency?

P Ramakrishnan
Aliran executive committee member
11 November 2015

The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

AGENDA RAKYAT - Lima perkara utama
  1. Tegakkan maruah serta kualiti kehidupan rakyat
  2. Galakkan pembangunan saksama, lestari serta tangani krisis alam sekitar
  3. Raikan kerencaman dan keterangkuman
  4. Selamatkan demokrasi dan angkatkan keluhuran undang-undang
  5. Lawan rasuah dan kronisme
Support our work by making a donation. Tap to download the QR code below and scan this QR code from Gallery by using TnG e-wallet or most banking apps:
Avatar photo
P Ramakrishnan has been an Aliran member since its inception in 1977, serving on our executive committee for 36 years, half of that period as Aliran's president (1994-2011). He continues to serve as an Aliran member, highlighting issues of public interest to a larger audience
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Stephen Tan Ban Cheng
13 Nov 2015 2.59pm

I detest your comment, narrowly confined as it is to your conviction perhaps that prisoners found guilty of any crime should be treated as dirt, and not as the human beings that they are. Forget about the personalities involved. Just look at the fact patterns. In this day and age – and never forget that we are in the 21st century, brother! – don’t you think it is about time we think out of the box and learn how to ensure humane treatment to all prisoners? If we start by saying that all human life is given by the Divine, then it is about time that we learn how to treat His creatures and creations with all the respect due to our Maker. Unless, of course, you hold the view that some human beings are made by the Divine while others are made by the Diabolical. All things said, brother, it boils down to this and just this: How high a regard do we as Malaysians have for our fellow Malaysians? Related to this question is of course how much respect do we as Malaysians owe… Read more »

12 Nov 2015 3.57pm

Likewise Ramakrishnan, this article is only your opinion which is based on blind conviction. If Anwar were to be treated overseas, then why shouldn’t the same thing to be accorded to every prisoners in the Malaysian prison system. Would you agree that next time the next criminal cries that he needs a specialist in Mount Sinai, he must given that opportunity be send there. If you answer “no” then you are not fair and impartial. If you say “yes” then I say “Wow!! Brilliant idea.” Then all Malaysians should commit crime so that you can have a chance to go overseas. Preferably those crimes are against you family. Anwar is nothing more than a criminal who specializes in giving excuses. Anwar was in the government before and yet nobody can truly say what did he accomplished during those times. Was he honest?? Ha! Ha! Ha! Go find out yourself. The truth is he has never been called Mr Clean. Anwar is brilliant salesman. He can sell you anything but like all salesmen, the after sales service will disappoint you. Go check records in school, my man… Read more »

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x