Home Newsletters 2014 Newsletters So what’s next for Pakatan?

So what’s next for Pakatan?

Why did Pas join Pakatan Rakyat in 2008?

Follow us on our Malay and English WhatsApp, Telegram, Instagram, Tiktok and Youtube channels.

Pas needs an overhaul; Hadi needs to be replaced; and the hegemony of the ulamas needs to be stopped, asserts Faisal S Hazis.


The ‘Kajang Move’ was a big flop. PKR failed to push its choice of Menteri Besar to lead the richest state in the country so as to propel Pakatan to Putrajaya in the next general election.

Although Pakatan Minus (with the exception of Pas) stood firm on their choice of candidate to the very last hours, the palace defied democratic convention by appointing someone else, Azmin Ali. Despite its resentment against the palace’s decision, the PKR and later the DAP endorsed Azmin’s appointment, thus sacrificing its principles and surrendering its power to choose the Menteri Besar. This spells trouble for the PKR’s already tainted and battered image.

The ‘Palace Move’ is not only going against democratic convention but it also calls into question the role of the constitutional monarch in our increasingly shrinking democracy. This should be a matter of concern not only to the opposition but also the BN since the ruling party’s prerogative in naming the prime minister and chief minister, as noted by former premier Mahathir Mohamad, would also be compromised. This spells trouble for democracy.

The Selangor crisis not only deepened factional fights in the PKR and Pas but it also amplified inter-party schism within Pakatan. Worse, the crisis exposed Pas’ true colors (i.e. its long obsession with the Islamic state agenda, its non-democratic culture via ulama control and a feudal state of mind) and its lack of commitment in upholding the spirit of Pakatan. Whatever happened to the notion of Negara Kebajikan Islam ,which was being touted by Pas in the last four general elections? This spells trouble for Pakatan.

READ MORE:  More than a 'silly season'?

So, what’s next for Pakatan? Is this the beginning of the end for the young coalition? Can Pakatan consolidate and regain the people’s trust in being a viable alternative to BN?

The future certainly looks gloomy for Pakatan Rakyat. Under the leadership of out of favour PKR deputy president Azmin Ali, the PKR, together with DAP and Pas, has a daunting task of putting Selangor back on the ‘right’ track.

The newly installed government needs to address all the issues associated with the Khalid leadership and fulfil Pakatan’s promises to the people of Selangor. If it can do this, Pakatan has a fighting chance in the next general election. However, inter- and intra-party factional fights are expected to continue plaguing Pakatan, thus distracting it from its goal of ‘fixing’ Selangor.

An even bigger challenge for Pakatan is to consolidate the coalition. The Selangor crisis shows that Pas is a liability to Pakatan. Its commitment to the coalition is in serious question. Its renewed call for the introduction of hudud and Islamic state is a betrayal of its electoral promise to moderate Malays and non-Muslims.

Hadi Awang’s actions in the Selangor crisis expose his lack of respect towards new politics and the spirit of the opposition coalition. Pas needs an overhaul. Hadi needs to be replaced. The hegemony of the ulamas needs to be stopped. The struggle for a welfare state, democracy and inclusivism should precede other agendas. If not, Pakatan has to cut its ties with Pas. Failing which, Pakatan would not even stand a chance to put up a credible challenge in the next general election.

READ MORE:  Mahathir's 'Malay Proclamation' underestimates Malays' common sense

Pakatan, however, has some breathing space because BN is equally hopeless. It fails to understand the impulse of the majority of voters in 2013 who wanted an inclusive, democratic and transparent Malaysia. But to form a government, Pakatan cannot rely on BN’s weaknesses only. Without a united coalition with a strong commitment towards change, Pakatan would only be a noisy opposition. Nothing more, nothing less.

Faisal S Hazis

Co-editor, Aliran e-Newsletter

27 September 2014

The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

AGENDA RAKYAT - Lima perkara utama
  1. Tegakkan maruah serta kualiti kehidupan rakyat
  2. Galakkan pembangunan saksama, lestari serta tangani krisis alam sekitar
  3. Raikan kerencaman dan keterangkuman
  4. Selamatkan demokrasi dan angkatkan keluhuran undang-undang
  5. Lawan rasuah dan kronisme
Support our work by making a donation. Tap to download the QR code below and scan this QR code from Gallery by using TnG e-wallet or most banking apps:
Avatar photo
Dr Faisal S Hazis, an Aliran executive committee member and co-editor of our newsletters, is the author of Domination and Contestation: Muslim Bumiputera Politics in Sarawak (2012).He is presently a senior fellow at the Institute of Malaysian and International Studies (Ikmas), UKM. His research interests include electoral politics, democratisation and rural informatics.
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Lim Teck Hing
Lim Teck Hing
28 Sep 2014 6.21pm

Although Pakatan was blamed for the Selangor MB crisis by the palace, it was Pakatan who made the palace look good at the end. For a personal decision that defies the democratic process and the state constitution, Pakatan’s principle in upholding democracy was compromised by the palace’s decision.

If Pakatan have not changed their support at the final hour for Azmin, the crisis will be prolonged as the palace would have appointed someone who does not command the majority support of the state assembly. As rightly stated by Dr., the palace would not have been able to do this during Tun M’s time.

28 Sep 2014 12.56am

There is a cancer inside Pakatan that should be excised soon to save the rest of the coalition. It is not pleasant, but better do it sooner rather than later. Otherwise, leaving it to fester will destroy the entire coalition. Will Pakatan call a spade a spade, and be willing to act now, or wait until the coalition is dead? That cancer is not PAS, but Hadi.

27 Sep 2014 10.19pm

Pas must make a choice either to stay or leave. If they want to stay with the coalition, they have to put their house in order. I doubt that will happen. They are still stuck in their self belief that they are in the right and the other partners must toe their line.

27 Sep 2014 11.16am

What is most needed next is a new leader for PKR, one who is genuinely dedicated to serve and also to look after the people of Malaysia. Most of all to bring back the true democracy this country needs after so many decades with Umno/BN. Time to move on and also to move forward for a truly democratic Malaysia without any fear of being locked up without trial and without any fear of being detained for uttering the truth !

27 Sep 2014 8.08am

Democracy is dead in Malaysia, it only, it was only there when the repugnant Mahathir was the PM. He was so mighty that even the monarch would just let him do anything he wanted and he recently said that during his time he only submitted one name for the post of MB. Why does that say ?
He can be seditious and even defy the police to have him arrested for being seditious. So much for the impartially for the police ! The law is only meant for the opposition(?)

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x