Home TA Online 2011 TA Online ‘No’ to Bersih, ‘Yes’ to Kotor?

‘No’ to Bersih, ‘Yes’ to Kotor?

Follow us on our Malay and English WhatsApp, Telegram, Instagram, Tiktok and Youtube channels.

Home Minister Hishammuddin Hussein says “Bersih” is still illegal. What about “Kotor”, wonders Curi-cuci Malaysia.

Prior to the announcement that the Bersih 2.0 event on 9 July 2011 would be held in a stadium, Home Minister, Hishamuddin Hussein and the police had issued warnings to the ‘rakyat’ not to join the coalition’s “Walk for Democracy” calling for free and fair elections.

The authorities arrested close to 200 peaceful demonstrators including opposition members of parliament, state assembly members, NGO volunteers and members, as well as some children as young as seven years old.

The offices and premises of some NGOs were raided; the Penang Suaram office was broken into by unknown persons, then Bersih’s secretariat in Petaling Jaya was raided by the police. Nothing seems to have been taken from the Penang Suaram office; instead a trail of broken locks and damaged doors was found. The police raided Bersih’s office, without a warrant, and carted away a number of T-shirts, pamphlets, posters, banners and computers. The mainstream media expectedly played up this news, but the exaggeration was too weak to be convincing. The public merely shook their heads at the pettiness of the issue or made cynical jokes about this sandiwara, produced by the Home Ministry in collaboration with Bukit Aman.

The situation typically reflected the idiom, “making a mountain out of a molehill”. In fact, this production is being viewed by the global community with some amazement (maybe amusement too). Foreign aquaintances even asked Malaysians, “So, your government doesn’t want free and fair elections?” – to which the embarrassing answer is, “Yes – our government does not want free and fair elections”. That’s the truth. One cannot defend the indefensible.

READ MORE:  Stop dragging the police into political war games

The current administration is living on another planet, probably a long way off somewhere beyond the Milky Way, as we know it. In that imaginary world of theirs, wearing particular coloured clothing with some slogan is an arrestable offence. Holding peaceful rallies and demonstrations is also an arrestable offence, and travelling on a chartered bus with T-shirts, pamphlets and banners is akin to waging war against the king. Even children accompanying parents on their day out can be arrested and detained for distributing pamphlets!

This must be “The World of the Stooges” where Malaysians are kept under a glass coconut shell, away from the rest of the world, but they can see what is happening on the outside through their transparent ‘tempurung’ (coconut shell). We see hundreds and thousands of people in many other countries all over the globe out on the streets protesting and professing their rights.

We know it is happening in Europe, Australia, North Africa, the Middle-East, Latin America and North America, even next door in Asean. But, in most instances, there is no violence until the baton-wielding police move in and start beating up unarmed protesters. What Malaysians find astonishing is that in many peaceful demonstrations in other countries, few police personnel are around and most of those on patrol are merely standing around watching the demonstration go by. The atmosphere is more like a carnival rather than an angry protest.

So, what’s so threatening about going out in large crowds to walk along and sing and chant in unison, dressed in slogan bearing T-shirts or wearing ghoul masks or other kinds of head or face gear. Dancing in the street should also be permitted like in Rio De Janeiro. Have a good shout and some exercise, ending with a good laugh and good-natured presentation of a memorandum to the relevant dignitaries, whom we hope will take the trouble to read it, if they don’t do anything else. If they don’t want to hear us, they’re not listening to the rakyat.

READ MORE:  Zarazilah elected as new Patriot president after Arshad's tenure ends

BN supporting ‘Kotor’?

Going back to the point that the BN regime doesn’t agree with ‘Bersih’ (Clean) – does it mean that the current government supports the opposite, which is ‘Kotor’ (Dirty)? Does the current government clearly give full support to unfair and unfree elections? Does it support money-politics, vote buying, registering phantom voters, vote rigging and a completely opaque system where under-handed practices and fraud operate in secrecy minus accountability?
Does it strongly support corrupt practices and cronyism using the MACC as a mere eye-wash for the rakyat and the world at large?

As it stands, the government wields the power to gag democratic voices with the ISA and other such laws in their arsenal that lack humanity or respect for human dignity. Perhaps, they are not human, after all?

When the rakyat is currently facing hardship with spiralling living costs due to increasing global prices of fuel, food and everything else, the powers-that-be deem that subsidies, including oil subsidies, must be removed. Perhaps, they think that the ‘rakyat’ drink petroleum to keep alive. We seem to be morons and robots to them.

Moreover, the Bersih 2.0 “Walk for Democracy” has also attracted the racist group Perkasa, on the ruling party’s side, probably followed by other far right mosquito groups to show how ‘democratic’ they are. Unfortunately, we aren’t so sure that these groups will stick to merely having a nice stroll and shout like those following the “Bersih 2.0 Walk for Democracy”.

Their understanding of ‘democracy’ possibly translates into ‘hooliganism’ or ‘vigilantism’. A juvenile understanding of democracy with guaranteed non-accountability. The intention of these groups is extremely predictable: they are proud of being ‘agent-provocateurs’ in any public gathering and probably support ‘Jijik’ (Foul) more than just ‘Kotor’ (Dirty). It would be very surprising if they proved us wrong.
The New Straits Times (30 June 2011) surprised the public, reporting that the Vice-President of Perkasa suggested that Perkasa should join Bersih! However, Perkasa president Ibrahim Ali was unavailable to confirm this. This surprise still doesn’t dispel any suspicions anyone may have of the motive for making such a statement. Does a leopard change its spots? Nobody could be less serious about this.

READ MORE:  Thailand’s military-appointed senators must vote responsibly on second PM vote

The public should ignore the mainstream media news or enjoy the ‘sandiwara’ provided by the government. Don’t swallow any information without examining it first. We, the ‘rakyat’ have to learn to separate the ‘true gold’ from the ‘fools gold’ and relinquish the habit of being too lazy to think. Time to wake up and Cuci-cuci (Wash)!

Cuci-cuci Malaysia is the pseudonym of an Aliran contributor.

The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

AGENDA RAKYAT - Lima perkara utama
  1. Tegakkan maruah serta kualiti kehidupan rakyat
  2. Galakkan pembangunan saksama, lestari serta tangani krisis alam sekitar
  3. Raikan kerencaman dan keterangkuman
  4. Selamatkan demokrasi dan angkatkan keluhuran undang-undang
  5. Lawan rasuah dan kronisme
Support our work by making a donation. Tap to download the QR code below and scan this QR code from Gallery by using TnG e-wallet or most banking apps:
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
11 Jul 2011 12.37pm


12 Jul 2011 6.48pm
Reply to  sam

Sam, if you are talking about some Ambiga that has jilted you or something, I can understand. But if you are referring to Datuk Ambiga Sreenevasan then I have to take offense on her behalf. You have got to be an UMNO blind supporter if you cannot see the towering personality that is Datuk Ambiga for her selfless sacrifice in the name of upholding truth and justice for all Malaysians. Not that I really expect you would understand what I just wrote above. Please, just talk about people in your league that you understand.

9 Jul 2011 9.57pm

Owh jadi Anwar tidak mahu serah DNA dia kat makamah tu korang OK jer la, no problem kalu anwar tak mahu buktikan dier tidak bersalah seperti yang keluar dari mulut dier…Si Ambiaga ni orh suruhan si Anwar ler…kebanyakan dari parti pembangkang ni orang Cina & india yg berduit dan mahu malaysia utamakan mereka lagi2x orang cina ni dah baut i annoying berlagak pandai jer bab negara sebab ekonomi dorg yg pegang..orang melayu ni plak jadi tukang buat huru hara mereka…tahniah ler.

9 Jul 2011 6.07pm

apa lah bodoh kau orang yang buat onak dapat hasil yang pak turut dapat apa. duduk diam2 dah lah …

7 Jul 2011 9.18pm

alahai i rasa boring le dgn pak hisham nape u latar sgt. u nak ajak ambiaga kelas undang-undang ke ? kahlid x abisx2 dgn permit , u orang lawan taukeh tau x . bagi la permit 2 . dok kalot sgt pasal pa . bukan nak perang pown .bersih di tolak , kotor di layan mmg prinsip BN . x ka rakyat x taw . Ckp x serupa bikin . sebenarnya dia nak baik pulih 8 perkara dlm spr . ayoyo 1 lagi . Suruhanjaya di Raja . AKAN DI TUBUH . AGAKX2 LE . X INGAT INDAI X SUPPORT , FLESHBACK CIKIT CERITA UDAYAKUMAR N 20,000 INDIANZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ,

7 Jul 2011 7.57am

The government of Malaysia had only two choices when faced with the challenge posed by Bersih. Either to say yes, allow it, or no to stop it. The first choice might open up the possibility of an informed public rejecting their dirty politics. The second choice would actually lead to the same result but in a delayed fashion. What they should have done is to ‘bersihkan’ their act but this was something they were not in a position to do. Thus they found themselves in a checkmate situation. A very good trap laid, perhaps unconciously by Bersih, but a good trap nonetheless. They are now between a hard rock and the deep blue sea. They can get crushed or they will drown. Either way they will perish. Serves them right.

6 Jul 2011 10.01pm

Kotor is the right word to describe UMNO BN from the more than 50 years of track records of oppressions of the Rakyats by using the Police Force as their tools of violence and blatant mismanagement of Malaysia with rampant corruptions and cheating and plundering the coffers of the Federal Government. Kotor is the word aptly describe UMNO BN and the underhand dirty tactics they use to suppress the press and misinform the general public of Malaysia. Malaysian of all races must get rid of this Kotor evil regime with the thorough cleansing by Bersih which is the spirits of the all the Rakyats for the wellbeing of all the future generations of all Malaysians in the next GE..

6 Jul 2011 9.56pm

All along UMNO has been pro-KOTOR, it’s obvious. Anyone can translate this in German or Latin for him when meeting the pope

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x