The government’s current concern over the allocation of PTPTN loans is just a piecemeal critique of a very wrong policy, that of privatised tertiary education, says Rani Rasiah.
The Higher Education Minister has been quoted as saying that the fund terms of the PTPTN would be reviewed to make sure only needy students would avail of it. This is not because the government has had a sudden change of heart favouring the poor. Rather in its typical cart before the horse style of doing business, it has discovered that PTPTN borrowers have defaulted to the tune of RM1 billion, and also that if not reviewed the government bill for private education would shoot up to RM5 billion by 2013.
What is needed is not a review of the PTPTN loan terms but a total revamp of the higher education system which has in great part been contracted out to private businessmen.
The reality of private education is that it has churned out more private education businesses than an educated population. Standards have been sacrificed – entry qualifications, teaching competency, practical training, accommodation – in the fierce competition for the easy PTPTN loans, the new cash cow for the well-connected companies operating colleges and universities. The last sitting of Parliament singled out a couple of private colleges as among the worst offenders, turning out substandard graduates whom hospitals are reluctant to employ.
- Sign up for Aliran's free daily email updates or weekly newsletters or both
- Make a one-off donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB a/c 8004240948
- Make a pledge or schedule an auto donation to Aliran every month or every quarter
- Become an Aliran member
The quality aside, private education places a heavy burden of debt on the shoulders of young graduates starting out life afresh, and determines the options they would have to take in life in order to survive. Someone trained to be a physiotherapist, for example, starts out working life with an outstanding loan of as much as RM60,000. It will take her at least 15 years to clear this debt, adding to the financial burden of raising a family and supporting the old folks.
At the other end of the scale, a doctor from a private medical university begins working life with a hefty debt of RM500,000. The future course of action is cut out for her – she has to earn as much as possible as fast as possible, settle the loan and then move on. Who is to be blamed if our young graduates seem individualistic, money-minded and uncaring?
Education is a public service that the government of the day is duty bound to provide, just like health care and basic amenities. It should be the overriding priority of government to invest in and make available universal quality education to its young in the best interests of the nation. Young adults with free education will be much more inclined to use their skills and knowledge for the benefit of the majority
The role of providing such education can never be replaced by the private sector whose overriding motive is profits by way of cutting costs
The government should take a leaf out of the progress achieved in education in countries like Venezuela, where genuine initiatives are being taken to ensure the educational needs of the population are met. Education is free, with meals thrown in as well, and flexible enough in terms of time and space to make sure every citizen can participate.
Education cannot be treated as just another commodity to be traded at the market place by institutions seeking to make a fast buck. The messy situation of tertiary education in the country is yet another example which confirms that certain services and functions should never be privatised. It is high time education is renationalised!
Rani Rasiah, an Aliran member, is deputy secretary general of Parti Socialis Malaysia