Home Web Specials Falling out of love in Georgetown City

Falling out of love in Georgetown City

Follow us on our Malay and English WhatsApp, Telegram, Instagram, Tiktok and Youtube channels.

Let not the mob and other detractors make us fall out of love with the arts and intellectual freedom, writes Mustafa K Anuar.

Quite often, a form of artistic expression, such as a theatrical performance, inadvertently gains more public prominence arising from an outburst of protest against it rather than as an outcome of its own publicity initiatives.

This is not to say that producers of artistic expression should be thankful for such “small blessings” especially when the upshot of such an angry protest is sheer censorship of their creative works.

A case in point is the play (not a film, as wrongly claimed by the protesters) Love in Georgetown City, which was staged at penangpac recently. Repeat performances after the first night of their artistic presentation were cancelled under mob pressure.

The protest was mounted by a group of self-styled moral guardians who apparently had not even watched the play; neither did they feel assured by police that the play does not promote free sex, the LGBT lifestyle and other forms of sexual aberration that they curiously envisioned.

It is most unfortunate that the Penang government stood silent over this violation of artistic expression. This is tantamount to acquiescence, which doesn’t augur well for the government’s professed desire to make George Town a city that is culturally vibrant, as exemplified by its well-known annual George Town Literary Festival.

Indeed, succumbing to such mob pressure is giving a wrong signal to those who are bent on placing obstacles to the growth of the arts in Penang and elsewhere in the country.

READ MORE:  The Southeast Asian Arts Censorship Database

It is important to note that the arts are as important as commerce, industry and science in the social, political and intellectual aspects of a progressive nation. Moreover, theatrical performances, just like film, dance, music, visual arts, photography and literature, are part and parcel of freedom of expression.

Thus, the banning of the this play in Penang should be the concern of not only theatre activists and buffs. A play is generally a popular art form as it can, if done deftly, tackle contemporary issues head on in a way that the audience can relate to, especially if it is executed through satire and humour.

True, the arts are an arena of struggle because they often allow space for experimentation to a certain degree by the producer. The arts can also provide a platform for various interpretations and many degrees of appreciation from the audience. Hence, one would expect the arts to elicit praise as well as provoke criticism, disagreement, controversy or even public protest.

But disagreement over a particular form of artistic expression should not border on threats of violence to the point of having it banned indirectly by an unruly mob.

Let’s take an example. Certain quarters in our society may not like the screening of horror or ghostly movies in cinemas – many of them have broken box office records – because, to them, it panders to superstition and the realm of illogic, which are considered unscientific and even insensitive to certain beliefs.

Although some individuals may want to stage protests in the cinemas concerned, it would be more intellectually beneficial if such protests take the form of civilised film reviews, commentaries or public dialogues.

READ MORE:  The Southeast Asian Arts Censorship Database

The banning of various forms of artistic expression is generally easy, but it is the epitome of intellectual laziness, if not shallowness – or even sheer arrogance.

It is only through intellectual engagement, such as literary criticism and dialogue, that public can be enlightened about the issue at hand. At the same time, such engagement can help to strengthen our intellectual tradition, if any. Brain is much preferred to brawn in this regard.

A nation is enriched in various ways, including the hard work and determination of creative people.

Let not the mob and other detractors make us fall out of love with the arts and intellectual freedom.

Source: themalaysianinsight.com

The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

AGENDA RAKYAT - Lima perkara utama
  1. Tegakkan maruah serta kualiti kehidupan rakyat
  2. Galakkan pembangunan saksama, lestari serta tangani krisis alam sekitar
  3. Raikan kerencaman dan keterangkuman
  4. Selamatkan demokrasi dan angkatkan keluhuran undang-undang
  5. Lawan rasuah dan kronisme
Support our work by making a donation. Tap to download the QR code below and scan this QR code from Gallery by using TnG e-wallet or most banking apps:
Avatar photo
Dr Mustafa K Anuar, a longtime executive committee member and former honorary secretary of Aliran, is, co-editor of our newsletter. He obtained his PhD from City, University of London and is particularly interested in press freedom and freedom of expression issues. These days, he is a a senior journalist with an online media portal
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Teo Chuen Tick
5 Mar 2019 5.16pm

The sad aspect of this incident is that the authorities bowed to the mob pressure and advised/called for the cancellation of the other performances.
Sigh…here in Penang not Kelantan/Terengganu!!

Khoo Soo Hay
Khoo Soo Hay
5 Mar 2019 11.54am

George Town should be an open city, that people from other countries would want to visit us, and see how we Penangites live in an environment free from racial, religious and gender bias, to show that we Penangites know how to respect each other’s lifestyle and enjoy the way we live our lives, with an open mind and respecting other people’s personal cultures.
It should not only be an open city, but also a free city. With that environment and ambiance, we will enjoy more tourist visitors and that will add to our state income.

4 Mar 2019 4.39pm

What nonsense and drivel! Just because a bunch of upper middle class pseudo intellectuals stage a pathetic play saturated in mind-numbing bourgeois values, that does not mean that it deserves any respect. Nay! It means that such pathetic attempts at “art” deserve to be persecuted! Such “art” merely extols middle class virtues and outlooks, and in the end propagate a vile, weak, consumer-centric human being. They should be continuously persecuted!
And what is so “intellectual” about Georgetown anyway? In all the so-called “intellectual circles” nothing of worth is discussed. No Heidegger, Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, Cicero or Heraclitus. Just self indulgent pseudo intellectual … from the gerak budaya crowd.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x