We, the undersigned organisations, wish to express our support for the development of a regional solution to the plight of the Rohingya that is founded upon a respect for their rights and draws upon the support of the international community. However, we are concerned that while regional solutions have been discussed, including at the recent Asean summit, some of the proposals suggested to date and some of the recent actions towards the Rohingya are in violation of their rights.
Background and recent developments
We recall the earlier statement of 6 February 2009 drafted by the Asia Pacific Refugee Rights Network in which grave concern was expressed about the well-being of more than one thousand Rohingyas from Burma (Myanmar) and migrants from Bangladesh who were forcibly expelled and abandoned in international waters by the Thai security forces since December 2008.
We express our grave concern at the attitudes and actions of the government of Burma towards the Rohingya over the last few weeks, including its disavowal of the Burmese citizenship of the Rohingya and its continuing violation of the rights of Rohingyas still residing in Burma. We are appalled at its racist characterisation of the Rohingya in recent diplomatic correspondence as “ugly as ogres”, which is emblematic of its flagrant discrimination against and gross mistreatment of the Rohingya. We note that these actions are the root cause of the displacement of the Rohingya within the region.
In contrast, we are pleased to observe that the Prime Minister of Thailand has admitted that Thai officials have pushed Rohingyas back to sea and that there have been no new reports of expulsion or refoulement from Thailand, Indonesia and India.
The requirements of any regional solution
In recent weeks, governments in the region have begun discussing “regional solutions” to the situation of the Rohingya.
We emphasise that any regional solution must be founded upon a recognition of and respect for the rights of the Rohingya. We are concerned that the Bali Process, the suggested forum for the negotiation of a regional solution, does not adequately focus on the rights of the Rohingya. In this regard, we remind states that any regional solution must be based upon the following principles:
- Refuge must be provided to those in need of international protection;
- No refugee or migrant should be forcibly returned (refouled) to Burma;
- The rights of refugees and migrants must be respected;
- The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) must be granted full, unconditional access to the Rohingya in states of the region; and,
- The international community must be included in and provide support to any regional solution.
1. Refuge must be provided to those in need of international protection
States have an obligation under international refugee and maritime law to grant safe harbour to boats in distress; the abandonment of people at sea is a grave breach of international law. During the past week, the Prime Minister of Malaysia threatened to “push back” any future refugees or migrants who arrive by sea. Such a threat is fundamentally incompatible with the humanitarian spirit of granting refuge and, if acted upon, is in violation of international law. A regional solution is only achievable if states share responsibility for the international protection of the Rohingya, not if they attempt to unilaterally shirk their obligations to refugees and neighbouring states. Any regional solution must provide refuge to those in need of international protection, including those stranded on the high seas.
2. No refugee or migrant should be forcibly returned (refouled) to Burma
Those who have fled Burma are at risk of rape, forced labour, forced eviction, land confiscation, prolonged and indefinite detention, and severe restrictions on freedom of movement. We note that Rohingyas crossing the Burmese border and sentenced for illegal re-entry constitute the majority of the prison population in North Arakan State (Burma) and that no international observers are allowed inside Burma to monitor the treatment of those imprisoned or those returning from abroad. In these circumstances, the mass voluntary repatriation of the Rohingya is not a viable option; any individual voluntary repatriation must be fully informed, genuinely voluntary and include guarantees of non-prosecution for illegal exit and full reintegration into communities in Burma. Any regional solution must guarantee explicitly that the Rohingya will not be subject to refoulement.
3. The rights of refugees and migrants must be respected
Arguments have been made that the Rohingya are migrants, not refugees, and therefore not entitled to international protection. We remind states in the region that even individuals who depart from their country of residence solely for economic reasons may nonetheless be refugees if they would face persecution for reasons of race, nationality, religion, political opinion or membership in a particular social group. We also remind states that migrants, including those in an irregular situation (so-called “illegal migrants”), are also entitled to various rights under international law. Any regional solution must accord international protection to refugees and respect the rights of migrants.
4. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) must be granted full, unconditional access to the Rohingya in states of the region
We call on states in the region to give unconditional access to UNHCR to all of the Rohingya in the region. In this regard, we decry the refusal of the government of Thailand to give the UNHCR access to these individuals unless the UNHCR committed not to make determinations of refugee status. Any regional solution must recognise the authority of the UNHCR concerning the international protection of refugees and the stateless, its role in the determination of status and must provide for the unconditional access of the UNHCR to the Rohingya throughout the region, including in Burma.
5. The international community must be included in and provide support to any regional solution
The international community must provide support for states in the region as they deal with the Rohingya. Specifically, the international community must provide financial assistance to countries of first asylum and guidance on best practices in dealing with mass influxes and rescue at sea. We are pleased by Australia’s offer of assistance to Indonesia and its current commitment to resettle a small number of Rohingya in the coming years. However, the support of the international community must increase; it must be directed at the protection of the rights of the Rohingya, and be long lasting.
In conclusion, the predicament of the Rohingya has been caused by the chronic and consistent violation of their rights by the government of Burma. Any solution will only be durable and effective if it fully respects and promotes the rights of the Rohingya in Burma and in the countries of the region. At a minimum, any regional solution must include the aforementioned provisions.
The predicament of the Rohingya underscores the ongoing need for a regional treaty to ensure the protection of refugees in the region in line with international standards. Unlike other regions, notably Africa and Latin America, there is no regional legal instrument governing refugee protection in Asia. We call on states in the region to commit themselves to the drafting of such an instrument, which would also eliminate the need for ad hoc policies to deal with refugee flows such as are being sought for the situation of the Rohingya. Such action would reaffirm the commitment of states in the region to the protection of human rights and would be consistent with the recent ratification of the Asean Charter and the development of an Asean human rights body.
5 March 2009
This statement was written by members of the Asia Pacific Refugee Rights Network (APRRN) and has been endorsed by the string of civil society groups.
Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.